For the U.S. Department of Agriculture (USDA) to give a food the coveted "organic" label, it has to pass some pretty rigorous checks. We're talking about strict guidelines covering soil quality, how animals are raised, pest and weed control, and even which additives are used. Organic farmers stick to natural substances and go the extra mile with methods that are physical, mechanical, or biologically based. For instance, your organic veggies are labeled as such only if they've been grown in soil free from prohibited substances for at least three years before harvest.

When it comes to baby formula, earning the "certified organic" badge means that at least 95% of the ingredients are organic.

But here’s a comforting nugget: whether your baby formula says "organic" on the tin or not, it has to meet the same stringent FDA nutritional standards before it lands on store shelves. This includes specific required amounts for 29 nutrients and caps for nine of them.

"All formula in the U.S. is tightly regulated by the FDA," assures Dr. Elena Shea, a pediatrician and international board-certified lactation consultant. "Organic or not, you’re getting the same nutrition."

So what exactly does “organic formula” mean? According to Dr. Shea, it means the formula has met higher standards for that certification. This includes being non-GMO, using certified organic ingredients and processing aids, and sticking to the National List of Allowed and Prohibited Substances. This means you’ll find fewer preservatives, flavors, and other additives in organic formulas compared to the standard ones."

Whether you're opting for formula or breastfeeding, Dr. Shea emphasizes, "The most critical thing is the health of both baby and mother. Formula is a great alternative for those who can’t—or choose not to—breastfeed. It will give your baby all the nutrition they need."

While all regulated baby formulas nourish your little one effectively, going organic offers some perks, primarily by reducing potential exposure to pesticides and other chemicals, says Dr. Shea.

Nutritionally, organic and non-organic formulas are quite similar, but there are “definitely presumed benefits of organic formula over the standard version, mainly due to reduced exposure to certain chemicals like pesticides,” concurs Caroline Brown, M.D., a pediatrician in Winston-Salem, North Carolina.

“Research has shown that pesticide exposure can impact young children’s cognitive and behavioral development[1],” she highlights. “However, the actual amount of pesticide your baby gets from standard formula is debatable and might not have any significant clinical effects.”

Indeed, it's good to know that the United States Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) ensures all pesticides used on U.S. foods meet strict safety standards set forth by the Food Quality Protection Act. This includes ensuring these pesticides are safe for kids. Plus, the FDA conducts annual checks on pesticide residues.

Navigating the formula aisle can feel like a Herculean task, especially for sleep-deprived parents. So, we’ve done the homework for you! We analyzed the price and nutritional components of over 80 baby formulas to identify the cream of the crop. Product details and prices are accurate as of the publication date.

The notorious price tag of organic baby formula. Just like its organic food cousins, it often commands a higher price compared to the conventional stuff.

"The cost is indeed the main downside of organic formula," says Dr. Brown. "But there's also the issue of not paying enough attention to the ingredients. Ideally, savvy parents would read the ingredient labels and understand aspects like sugar content and the best type of protein for their little ones."

A Guide to Selecting the Best Organic Baby Formula

It turns out you're not alone in your quest for the best organic baby formula. A 2020 study has shown that many parents in the U.S. are eyeing organic options from Europe[2]. But here's the catch: these formulas are often sold by third-party vendors and fall outside of the FDA's watchful eye. Yup, you heard that right! Researchers suggest that doctors could use a little extra training on the nuances of these European goodies. And, just so you know, the USDA’s 2020-2025 Dietary Guidelines give a thumbs down to formulas not FDA-regulated.

There are plenty of fantastic formulas bearing the coveted USDA-certified organic seal and are also regulated by the FDA. If you're leaning towards the organic route, check out these standout options:

LittleOak

LittleOak is a superstar in the baby formula universe. Coming from Australia, the company sources their organic goat milk from New Zealand and processes the milk using a natural process that retains the majority of the nutrients without having to add bad ingredients like palm oil.

• Nutrient-Rich: The most important factor in choosing baby formula for my kids is the nutritional aspect. We are a health-conscious family and seeing the organic & natural ingredients used in the formulas put LittleOak at the top of our list.
• The limited options: I liked that LittleOak found a recipe that works for each primary stage of a baby's development. We weren't overloaded with a variety of choices that needed deeper research to go through.
• The great taste: Compared with the other formula brands we tried, our babies loved the taste of LittleOak goat milk. No spitting up ever occurred and our babies were genuinely happy to be drinking the formula.
  
  

Bobbie

Bobbie is more than just a name; it's a game-changer in the baby formula market. This USDA-certified organic baby formula is inspired by breast milk and comes in a milk-based powder form with iron.

• Pasture-Raised Goodness: Their organic milk comes from cows that spend 42% more time on pasture than your average USDA requirement. That's a lot of moo-time!
• Brain-Boosting DHA: The DHA omega-3 is sustainably sourced, algae-based, and water-extracted (no hexane in sight!). This fatty acid is like brain food for your little one, supporting brain and eye development.
• Fat That Matters: The organic fat blend is modeled after the average fat profile of breast milk, offering essential fatty acids.
• Easy-Peasy Digestion: It contains whey and casein protein, both known to be easy on tiny tummies.